Bring Her Home
Family photographs of Jeannine

Missing from Melbourne, Florida

Bring Her Home

Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin

Last seen by her family on March 12, 2006. She was 33 years old, a mother of four, and she has never been found.

Missing for 20 years

Have information about Jeannine?

A Back in the Day: BREVARD Original

The Vanishing of Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin

A documentary about the girl from Sunwood Park, the woman her family still searches for, and the questions that remain about the night she disappeared. Running time about 19 minutes.

Who she was

The Girl from Sunwood Park

Jeannine was born in New Jersey on July 19, 1972. In 1979 her family moved south to Eau Gallie, Florida, and made their home in Sunwood Park, just off Aurora Road. She was seven. Her younger sister Jennifer was four.

She spent summers swimming at the Crane Field pool, played on a girls' softball team sponsored by Chuck E. Cheese, and counted Galaxy Skateway as a favorite gathering place. Later she became a familiar face at Sue's Wrangler, the small country diner near U.S. 192 and Dairy Road, where she worked for years.

She was a protective big sister, a daughter who stayed close to her mother, and the mother of four children who were between one and seven years old when she disappeared.

Family photographs of Jeannine arranged in an album
Family photographs, courtesy of Jeannine's family
  • SchoolsDr. W. J. Creel Elementary, Johnson Junior High, Central Junior High
  • Known to classmates asJ.C.
  • Worked atSue's Wrangler, Melbourne
  • Lived onWestwood Drive at one point; Plompton Drive in Sherwood Park in March 2006

What is known, and what was reported

March 2006

March 12
2006
Published accounts

Jeannine is last seen by her family at the home on Plompton Drive in the Sherwood Park neighborhood of Melbourne. According to accounts of the disappearance, her purse and cellphone were left behind.

The reported
call
Husband's reported account

Her husband reportedly said Jeannine called from a payphone along U.S. Highway 1, sounding frightened and asking for her mother. Published accounts placed the call near Grant. The family's later recollections place it in the Palm Bay area near Port Malabar Boulevard.

Jeannine was never found at that payphone, and there was no proof that she had ever been there. Her mother searched U.S. 1 into the early morning hours.

March 19
2006
Official report

The official missing-person report is made, about one week after she was last seen.

The following
month
According to Jennifer

Telephone records were obtained and given to authorities. Jennifer says they did not show the incoming call her husband described.

The telephone records have not been independently verified.

An unanswered lead

The New Haven Avenue Tip

About ten years ago, a tip came in claiming that Jeannine was buried near Interstate 95 at New Haven Avenue, in the area where the hotels, the Chuck E. Cheese, and the RaceTrac stand today.

The timing is what makes it worth asking about. As best the production understands it, that stretch near the interchange was mostly undeveloped land in 2005 and 2006, before the businesses there now were built. If the tip is true, the ground it describes may have changed a great deal since then.

This tip has not been verified. The production does not know whether it was investigated or whether the area was ever searched, and the timing of development in that area has not been confirmed.

What the tip claimed

That Jeannine was buried near I-95 and New Haven Avenue, in the area of the hotels, the Chuck E. Cheese, and the RaceTrac.

When it came in

About ten years ago, roughly a decade after she was last seen.

What is not known

Who gave the tip, whether it was followed up, and whether that area was ever searched.

What would help

If you remember what that land looked like in 2006, saw digging or unusual activity there around that time, or know anything about this tip, contact Melbourne Police at 321-608-6731 or CrimeLine at 1-800-423-TIPS.

Key places in Jeannine's story Simplified illustrated map of the Melbourne and Palm Bay area with numbered pins for the places described on this page. Not to scale. INDIAN RIVER ATLANTIC OCEAN I-95U.S. 1 DAIRY RDAURORA RD U.S. 192NEW HAVEN AVEPORT MALABAR BLVD EAU GALLIEMELBOURNEPALM BAYGRANT, FARTHER SOUTH 1 2 3 4 5 6
Illustration only. Not to scale; roads are simplified and pin locations are approximate.

Where her story happened

The Places in Her Story

  1. 1

    Sunwood Park, off Aurora Road

    The neighborhood her family moved to in 1979, when she was seven.

  2. 2

    Sue's Wrangler, near U.S. 192 and Dairy Road

    The country diner where she worked for years.

  3. 3

    Plompton Drive, Sherwood Park

    Where her family last saw her on March 12, 2006.

  4. 4

    U.S. 1 payphone, as published

    Published accounts placed the reported call near Grant.

  5. 5

    U.S. 1 payphone, as the family recalls

    The family's later recollections place it in Palm Bay near Port Malabar Boulevard.

  6. 6

    New Haven Avenue at I-95

    The area named in the burial tip that came in about ten years ago. The tip has not been verified.

Case updates

Latest Updates

New developments in the search for Jeannine will be posted here, newest first.

  1. The Documentary and This Page Are Released

    Back in the Day: BREVARD releases The Vanishing of Jeannine Carfi Arnold Erwin and launches Bring Her Home to keep her story in front of the public.

MISSING
Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin
Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin
Missing from Melbourne, Florida since March 2006

As described in the public missing-person record

Have You Seen Jeannine?

Age when last seen
33
Born
July 19, 1972
Eyes
Blue
Hair
Brown
Tattoos
Butterfly on her chest, four-leaf clover on her ankle, heart with wings on her shoulder
Scar
Extending from her chest toward her abdomen

Someone may remember

If You Know Something

A conversation. A car. A person. A detail from March 2006 that seemed small at the time could matter enormously today. You do not need to be certain to call.

Melbourne Police Department

321-608-6731

Melbourne, Florida. Reference Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin, missing since March 2006.

CrimeLine

1-800-423-TIPS

Share information anonymously.

Did you know Jeannine?

Share a Memory

Sign up with your name and email to leave a memory, talk with others who knew her, or send a private tip. Every post is reviewed before it appears.

Case records and coverage

Read More About Jeannine

Official records, case profiles, and news coverage from outside this production. Each link opens in a new tab.

Twenty years is long enough

Share Her Story

Every share puts Jeannine's face in front of someone new. If you grew up in Sunwood Park, went to school with J.C., or remember her from Sue's Wrangler, please pass this page on.

Missing poster for Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin Download the Poster

One page, US Letter. Ink-saver version for home printers.

QR code linking to this page

Scan to open this page